Saturday, June 5, 2010
THE REAL MIKE LEE
Friday, June 4, 2010
Mike Lee's position on social security? Total Horseshit says expert
Is Social Security unconstitutional?
Timothy Smeeding, a professor at the University of Wisconsin at Madison who studies Social Security, was blunt in his assessment of Lee's proposal: "That is total horseshit."
Senate candidates take stands on Social Security reform
Safety net » Lee questions constitutionality of Social Security
By Robert Gehrke
The Salt Lake Tribune
Utah's Republican Senate candidates have outlined a vision for reforming Social Security that includes raising retirement ages, private accounts and, in Mike Lee's case, taking the retirement safety net away from the federal government and letting states run it.
"Somewhere down the road we need to ask: Is the federal government the right government to be administering this?" Lee asked. "You don't find a retirement system in [the Constitution]. That, with the 10th Amendment, says it's a program best administered by the states."
Lee's proposal would mark a historic shift in the 75-year-old program, which the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in three cases in 1937 is a constitutional exercise of federal power.
Timothy Smeeding, a professor at the University of Wisconsin at Madison who studies Social Security, was blunt in his assessment of Lee's proposal: "That is total horseshit."
"What happens to people who move in and out of the state? It's just knee-jerk," he said. "[Social Security] is a federal program. It covers you no matter where you live and as long as you live."
With workers moving between states, a state-by-state patchwork is an idea that is impractical and should be discarded, Smeeding said.
KSL also reports the Mike Lee Lobbyist story
SALT LAKE CITY -- Republican candidate for U.S. Senate Mike Lee is being accused of working as a lobbyist last year without ever registering as a lobbyist.
A complaint was filed with the lieutenant governor's office concerning Lee's activities in 2009 as he listed 1-800 Contacts as a client. State Sen. Steve Urquhart pushed a trademark bill that 1-800 Contacts wanted to see passed, and Urquhart says he worked with a team of lobbyists including Mike Lee.
"He actually was a fairly effective lobbyist. I think he did well on it," says Urquhart. "Was he back there trying to help sell the bill? Yes is the answer."
State law requires lobbyists to register, and people can be fined for not doing so.
Mike Lee's spokesman responded to the accusations reported in the Salt Lake Tribune calling the complaint a last-minute smear of Lee's campaign. He even called Urquhart a henchman of his GOP Senate opponent Tim Bridgewater.
Urquhart says he's not taking sides in this issue and was surprised by the harsh words directed at him from Lee's campaign. Urquhart says he didn't know Lee wasn't registered as a lobbyist until recently and he was simply answering media questions about the 2009 bill.
Lee's campaign has said his work with 1-800 Contacts was not as a lobbyist and he cleared the issue with the lieutenant governor's office a year ago.
The Tribune also reports Lee's spokesperson says this is an attempt to hide Bridgewater's record of lobbying.
Bridgewater did register as a lobbyist in Congress in behalf of a foreign company, but he says he never ended up doing any lobbying work.
(KSLNEWS)
Sen. Steve Urquhart Responds "Mike Lee Lobbyist Issue"
"It is a last minute attempt, two weeks before an election, by Tim Bridgewater's henchman, Steve Urquhart, to smear Mike Lee over an action he fully cleared with the Lt. Governor's office a year ago." articleIn response to the Lee campaign's attack, Sen. Steve Urquhart wrote the following >>
MIKE LEE LOBBYIST ISSUE
June 4, 2010
by Senator Steve Urquhart
Yesterday, someone filed a complaint about Mike Lee failing to register as a lobbyist. I don’t know who filed the complaint.
Because the lobbying involved a bill I championed, reporters asked me whether Lee had lobbied on the Hill. The answer is yes. Simple enough, right?
Because I answered the reporters’ questions, the Lee campaign called me a “henchman” for Tim Bridgewater (who, though I now support after Bennett’s defeat, I hadn’t really spoken with for 8 years prior to Lee’s immaculate lobbyist claims). Why the unhinged response by Lee? Does Lee think I should have “no commented” the questions? Does he think I should cover for him? Is he sending a message to the world that Mike Lee won’t tolerate scrutiny? Or does he simply have really thin skin? In any event, it’s weird behavior by Lee.
Did Lee lobby? Yes. Many senators and lobbyists could verify that. For example, this article notes that Lee’s friend, who is neutral in the race (but did host An Evening on the Constitution event for Lee), and who was working against us on the bill in question, also replied to media’s inquiries by stating that Lee lobbied. It’s simply not true that Lee didn’t lobby.
Many lobbyists, including Mike, add to the political process by succinctly sharing information and fielding technical questions. I don’t believe that anyone is saying he conducted himself in an inappropriate manner while lobbying. I personally asked Senators to meet with him about the bill, and while we sat there, he lobbied them. He did a fine job. It simply is a question whether he should have registered. If he believes he has a suitable answer, why not simply give it?
Lee is griping about the timing of the complaint. Is it political? Of course it is, but Lee seems to be the one who triggered the issue. He is the one who indignantly stated that Bridgewater is a lobbyist. The complaint appears designed to point out that Lee’s charges are hypocritical. It was a stupid political move on his part, and he got called on it.
U.S. Senator Mike Lee accused of unlawful lobbying
U.S. Senator Mike Lee accused of unlawful lobbying
Max RothFOX 13 News
5:21 PM MDT, June 3, 2010
SALT LAKE CITY - Two days in 2009 could be causing U.S. Senate Candidate Mike lee trouble. That year, corporations were fighting each other over legislation proposing rules overseeing who has rights to keyword search terms online. Two state senators, Steve Urquhart of Washington County and Dan Liljenquist of Davis County, tell Fox 13 Lee was working at the state capitol for at least two days talking to senators on behalf of a client, 1-800-CONTACTS. Lee's campaign countered with a strongly worded statement saying he cleared his activity with the Lt. Governor's office. Lee's statement also leveled accusations against Tim Bridgewater.
Lobbying is legal and both senators tell Fox 13 Mike Lee acted appropriately, but paid lobbyists have to register, according to state law. Fox 13 confirmed with the state elections office Lee never did register.
Text of Lee's campaign statement:
"This is nothing more than a thinly veiled attempt to hide Mr. Bridgewater's own record of lobbying Washington, D.C. for foreign companies, and pushing their overseas interests upon our government. It is a last minute attempt, two weeks before an election, by Tim Bridgewater's henchman, Steve Urquhart, to smear Mike Lee over an action he fully cleared with the Lt. Governor's office a year ago. The timing is suspect and disgusting and voters will see through this.
"Mr. Lee had checked with the Lt. Governor's office and talked with Attorney Michael Cragun before engaging in any activity on the hill and was informed that his role of answering questions as to the constitutionality of any proposed legislation did not trigger or meet any filing or reporting requirements," says Boyd C. Matheson, Communication Director.
From Bridgewater's campaign statement:
Press Secrtary, Tiffany Gunnerson says: "These allegations have been out there for a while. We've known about this, the lGS office has known about this and the only reason this is surfacing now is because Mike Lee has launched into the politics of hypocrisy"
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Mike Lee does not take his own advice
US Senate candidate
Mike Lee does not take his own advice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PuC9QEbw3MY
Previous to convention, I promoted the following principle:
“You are trying to promote and defend a candidate, not attack others trying to do the same. Target candidate issues, records, statements, or possible conflicts of interest. No writing about family member…s or character assassination.”
That principle was something both the Eagar, Bennett and Bridgewater campaigns generally seemed to follow. A principle many of the Lee supporters would not follow. It cost Mike Lee at convention. After, Mike and campaign claimed those people were just being rogue, [even those with campaign titles] and said they would and could not control them.
When other campaigns before the convention went after Mike’s statements, he said they shouldn’t do that, he wouldn’t do that, and usually implied they were lying.
Now that Mike is doing exactly what he said he wouldn’t do, I assume he wants us to now ignore him and ask the other guy what the truth is.